Gift Economy and Earnestness - A Solar Punk Future

The following was written for a new section we are developing on Cloudie.so called “The Love Moat,” which aims to explore Sanctum’s and fp’s philosophy:


Ever since I started reading Sanctum founder FP Lee’s writings on their approach to distributing their new token, $CLOUD, and the concept of Earnestness, I’ve been deeply impressed by how such meaningful philosophy is being put into practice. Finding this level of thoughtfulness and humanity in the financial world was something I didn’t expect, but crypto always finds a way to surprise us!

In his other texts, FP engages in sincere questioning of the “why” and the “what” behind everything they are doing and building, which marks something truly important. He acknowledges how crypto is revolutionary, making it a big part of the “why”:

crypto can improve the lives of billions. we can release people from the tyranny of governments and hyperinflationary fiat. we can pioneer new, wonderful methods of collaboration and value creation. we can run fun experiments with magic internet money. this is a beautiful bulldozery sandbox for us to build the future at lightspeed, without getting tangled up in red tape or blocked by blankface bureaucrats.
forget the shitcoins. the real way we hypergamble into omegawealth is by showing up and building shit that’s so good, the rest of the world can’t help but come. be serious, be earnest. everything else is a distraction from the Vision – fuck it, ignore it.
remember, in your heart of hearts, why you’re really here." (source)

Getting to the “what” can be trickier. What exactly is Sanctum? It’s not just another “liquid-stake protocol” on Solana, and their actions show why it’s more than that. Their scope is expanding, and their partnerships with other protocols and projects demonstrate their ambition to build something much greater, and to make crypto a better place for everyone.

One thing that stands out about their new token and the airdrop they distributed is that they reserved 50% of the tokens for the community. This innovative move drew criticism from some, but the critics didn’t seem particularly thoughtful. After all, why criticize someone for giving out a gift? Whoever is offering the gift has the right to decide who receives it and why. And Sanctum clearly knows who they wish to reward. Rather than following conventional and superficial methods of allocation, they chose to measure contributions by Earnestness - the deep sincerity, dedication and alignment to the project’s vision.

To them, true value lies in genuine engagement, driven by conviction, not in speculative interest and opportunism. Through this thoughtful distribution, Sanctum is cultivating a culture of earnest participation, ensuring that those who receive the gift are not only committed to the ecosystem but are also genuinely aligned with its core principles.

The crypto bubble is already bursting, and soon there will be no distinction between crypto and everything else - if there ever was. Web3 is the new internet, and it will go mainstream in no time. When I listen to FP, I don’t just hear him talking about crypto, I hear him discussing the principles that guide us all.

All that reminds me of something I find deeply inspiring: the Gift Economy. It’s a philosophy I hold close, especially as an artist. Selling art is challenging because value is subjective, so I began letting clients pay what they felt was fair and affordable to them. This experiment revealed how they valued my work and embodied the essence of generosity, as each exchange became a shared gift.

Researchers (like Heide Göttner-Abendroth) have extensively explored both historical and remaining matriarchal societies. Before money, exchanges were made directly through goods, and value was as subjective as it is today. It depended on how important or scarce items were to individuals. For instance, if you had plenty of one item but lacked another, you’d trade with someone who had what you needed. If you had a big surplus, like from a bountiful harvest, you’d often share it with the community. Nothing was hoarded, as is often the case today. These offerings, often made by family clans through large feasts, were a way to give back to the community. Such acts of generosity earned recognition, reinforcing bonds and fostering mutual respect and cooperation.

At their core, those societies emphasize mothering and parenting with a focus on treating others as one would treat their own children. In this philosophy, a just parent makes no distinctions between their children, ensuring that all are treated equally. This egalitarian value forms the foundation of these societies, where cooperation and fairness are prioritized over hierarchies and dominance. This challenges traditional notions of power and governance, offering a vision where leadership is rooted in empathy, care, and collective well-being. Such perspectives provide valuable insights into reimagining leadership, governance, community building, and societal structures today.

Before today’s globalized world, local cultures were much more common. The world was more plural and decentralized, with countless diverse forms of organization and social interaction. This diversity brought richness and depth. Now, looking ahead to crypto and Sanctum - as FP said, crypto enables us to pioneer new methods of collaboration and value creation. We are no longer bound by government-controlled money with all its restrictions and centralization. Instead, we can create our own currencies and build decentralized subcultures, each with its own communities, economies, coins, symbols, and values. This is key to understanding what Sanctum truly is. Like I said, it’s not just a “liquid-staking protocol”. With its own vibrant community, token, and role in Solana’s ecosystem, Sanctum is pushing the boundaries of what crypto can truly be.

And beyond that, Sanctum offers something unexpected: a Philosophy. A set of principles and values that shape its identity. It becomes clear that Sanctum is indeed like a clan, a family, a school, a sanctuary.

Another philosophy to consider for the future we’re building is the Solar Punk ideology. In contrast to the dystopian Cyberpunk vision of environmental ruin and technological oppression, Solar Punk envisions a vibrant future where technology harmonizes with nature and enriches human life (like this). It represents a shift from destructive systems to integrated, sustainable living. With its sunny name and innovative approach, Solana is well-suited to advance this mindset, paving the way for a future where technology fosters a healthier, more sustainable world.

As we approach the end of this remarkable year for Sanctum and enter the holiday season, it’s the perfect time to reflect more on the philosophy of gifting. Everything we do in life comes full circle, and when we embody generosity, kindness, and inclusivity, we invite these qualities back into our lives. Let’s carry this spirit of giving with us throughout the year, allowing it to guide our actions beyond the holiday season.

People who still believe in something can inspire others to embrace a better, more humane way of living. A small seed has been planted, and it’s beginning to grow into something truly meaningful, that can become as great as we can dream it to be. Humanity deserves more than what we’ve known so far, and together, we can start to build that earnest new world.

19 Likes

You can feel the warmth as soon as you read the article. :revolving_hearts:

5 Likes

I love where your head is at, I just don’t know if it’s where reality is or will ever be.
In ‘Love Moat’ (which you referenced) there is a line you hear often in crypto about an airdrop changing people’s lives.
Those people sold those airdrops. You can’t change your life with CLOUD. You can if you dump it for USDC and cash that out though. And for all those “changed lives” were a lot more loyal CLOUD holders who got dumped on.
So there’s already a bit of dissonance there. You got your life changed? Great. Thanks for dumping my token price.

It’s where GroupOn and that whole sector that sprung up around them were years ago. Whole thing blew up to the 100’s of billions in market size until businesses got sick of funding freebies that never actually resulted in positive returns and once the freebies dried up that user cohort, who were never there to become new customers, left quickly and the sector crashed hard.

The only thing genuinely making money is gambling. Memecoins are pure fees and fully diluted. There’s nothing artificially holding them up and they are THE PMF that is generating the fees that make everything else work (especially LSTs). Without them there’s still nothing that’s drawn any kind of sustained interest on chain and we’ll be back to $25 SOL in no time (and I do not want to go back there any time soon).

All this is to say, I think it’s going to be very very hard to get a gifting economy that ever is able to replace a meaningful slice of the economy on chain which is supported by ongoing incentive schemes and gambling.
The only way (I can see) is we get a whole bunch of much differently aligned users on chain. Which means we have to focus all our energy on onboarding to the short term detriment of current users. A painful path to navigate to be sure.

5 Likes

:safety_pin:
FP Lee’s emphasis on “Earnestness” as a criterion for token distribution is indeed a novel approach in a sector often criticized for speculative greed. By focusing on genuine engagement and alignment with the project’s vision, Sanctum aims to create a community that’s not just invested financially but also philosophically in what they are building. This resonates with the broader crypto ethos of decentralization and community-driven governance but takes it a step further by integrating a moral and cultural dimension into the token economy.

Your parallel between Sanctum’s airdrop strategy and the Gift Economy is insightful. In traditional gift economies, value is not determined by market forces but by social relationships and mutual aid. Sanctum’s approach to rewarding community members based on their earnest contributions rather than just capital investment mirrors this ethos. It suggests a move towards a more communal, less transactional model of value exchange within crypto ecosystems.

Drawing from Heide Göttner-Abendroth’s research, you’ve connected historical practices to contemporary community building in crypto. The idea of treating community members like family, with equal care and without hierarchical distinctions, presents a compelling model for how crypto projects like Sanctum might operate. This aligns with the decentralized, egalitarian ideals that many in the crypto space advocate for, aiming to create systems where power and benefits are more equitably distributed.

The vision of crypto enabling diverse, decentralized communities with their own economies and values reflects a return to or evolution of pre-modern societal structures. Sanctum, by fostering its own culture and community, exemplifies this potential, showing that blockchain technology can be a tool for cultural as well as economic revolution.

The mention of Solar Punk in relation to Solana’s ecosystem is particularly apt. It suggests a future where technology serves ecological and social good, moving away from the dystopian narratives often associated with tech-heavy scenarios. This ideology dovetails with crypto’s potential to democratize access to resources and encourage sustainable practices through decentralized systems.

Your call to reflect on the philosophy of gifting during the holiday season encapsulates the broader message of your post. It’s a reminder that the technologies and communities we are building can and should embody values of generosity and inclusivity, not just for the sake of transactions but for fostering genuine human connections and societal well-being.

In summary, Sanctum, through FP Lee’s philosophical approach, is pioneering a model where cryptocurrency isn’t just a means of financial exchange but a platform for cultural, social, and ethical experimentation. This approach could serve as a blueprint for how other projects might integrate more human-centric values into their operations, potentially reshaping what we expect from financial and technological innovations.

Luv ya Lucio :vulcan_salute:

3 Likes

Agree that this is a non traditional approach and would be very rewarding in the long term. People come in for airdrop but some would inevitably stay and contribute for this community.

Fudders are everywhere however the vision keeps me in the community and can’t wait for whatever that’ll be coming.

Cheers, merry christmas.

4 Likes

Hi Andrew! Thanks for your comment! I do disagree with some of your points. The first thing is that in order to change people’s lives doesn’t mean that they will all dump, and sell it all at once. Also, the data (here and here) shows that more than half of the earnestness allocation is still being vested.

The deeper you dive into crypto and DeFi, the value of coins can be independent of their value in USD. For example, when you list something for sale in SOL, you won’t adjust the price daily just because SOL’s value in USD is fluctuating. We are creating our own economy, and one day, it will be completely independent of fiat. I’m sure this will start to happen soon with BTC, ETH, and SOL, and as I’ve mentioned regarding truly decentralized subcultures, we will eventually see multiple parallel economies, each with its own coins that hold intrinsic value within their respective communities.

I’ve already experienced this with $CLOUD. The way we’ve used it within the community, for grants, rewards (which I’m very glad you took part in), etc, wasn’t necessarily measured by converting it to USD. In our ecosystem, 100 $CLOUD can be worth 100 $CLOUD, and that’s it. As we continue to build more utility for it, this concept will only become more apparent and meaningful.

I really don’t like the idea of meme coins and gambling driving the crypto space. From my perspective, DeFi is much more than that. It’s the new financial system, and it should be the other way around, memes should be a much smaller part of it. Hopefully, this is just another passing trend, like so many others before it, and DeFi and crypto will be valued for their serious projects. While memes can help build communities, real value should reflect the significance and broader impact of a project within the ecosystem. To me, this is how we can truly grow DeFi’s scope as a revolutionary force in market dynamics and in the way we conduct business and trade around the world.

The gift economy and earnestness serve as great examples of how trading isn’t always a precise science. Value is subjective and constantly shifting. Gifts can be woven into all kinds of exchanges and transactions. When you offer something in exchange for something else, the outcome will always vary depending on factors such as timing, who’s involved, and the context of the exchange. You can assign value to things that defy precise monetary quantification, and any transaction may contain a “gift” element, manifested in the difference between what something “should” cost and what is actually paid for it. This is particularly evident in the world of art. When you buy a piece of art, you’re not only acquiring the artwork, but you’re also directly supporting the artist, contributing to their livelihood, and acknowledging the broader value of their creativity and effort.

Airdrops are also great examples. They were originally intended as a way to thank users and the community. However, when they’re over-exploited, turned into mandatory reward systems, and expected to follow specific rules, it undermines the very concept of a gift. A gift is something given willingly, not out of obligation. The giver always has the freedom to decide how much to give, to whom, and in what way. Airdrops have undergone many changes recently, and they will continue to evolve. Earnestness has set an amazing precedent, shifting the focus into a new, more human-centered direction.

For a true gift economy to work, people would need to be way more generous and genuinely care about what they’re engaging with, seeing the people behind all the numbers. It’s not something that’s likely to happen overnight, but it’s worth dreaming about and hoping for. Even if we don’t get all the way there, every little step we take in that direction is still a win. Let’s keep holding on to our utopian dreams, because if we give up on them, we might end up getting caught up in the alluring and destructive world of dystopias.

5 Likes

Im so glad i found this community is so great to read everything that you guys do.

4 Likes

You’re an idealist. So am I (despite the pessimism I feel at times).
Idealists are all crazy.
You can’t build anything completely new without being crazy.

3 Likes

Beautifully written @luciotamino! You put it better than I could. Thank you so much for sharing.

4 Likes

Thanks, I’m also glad to hear this, to know our musings are appreciated! hehe

Yes man, we can all get caught up in pessimism, and I know I do at times too. But as you said, we can also try to see things from different “crazy” angles and realize there are great possibilities that might just work out, especially if we at least give them a shot. What do we really have to lose, right? In this context, being “crazy” is also about clearing our minds of all the outside noise and pollution, and allowing ourselves to dream, letting go of the limitations and restrictions we’ve always been taught. We’re living in revolutionary times! Haha. Who knows what the future might hold?

Thank you so much for your words, fp! I really love your texts and ideas, so this is just a reflection of the connection I feel. Being part of a project that actually puts these kinds of ideas into practice is incredibly heartwarming and refreshing! Sanctum will definitely be a beacon of hope for everyone who feels the way we do! Let’s spread the word and make it shine! :sparkles::seedling: